Showing posts with label Menis. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Menis. Show all posts

Wednesday, September 26, 2018

TFBT: Who is the goddess of Menis?


My friend Maya asked about the lameness of Hephaestus.  I am going to ramble a bit answering.   The myths of Hephaestus lameness are over the place.
  • ·      He was lame at birth due to his parthenogenesis. (Homer, Odyssey 8.267) 
  • ·      His was lame because he was lame at birth and his mom threw him off Olympus.  (Homer, Iliad 18.140)
  • ·      He was lame because he got between his bickering parents and got tossed. (Apollodorus, Bibliotheca 1.19)

All this is sort of beside the point; Hephaestus was the prototype for Typhon.  There are several accounts of Typhon’s conception, but the one including Hera involves a male deity this time

Hephaestus was not as scary as his brother, but there was a tale of his menis;

"[In the temple of Dionysus at Athens :] There are paintings here--Dionysus bringing Hephaistos up to heaven. One of the Greek legends is that Hephaistos, when he was born, was thrown down by Hera. In revenge he sent as a gift a golden chair with invisible fetters. When Hera sat down she was held fast, and Hephaistos refused to listen to any other of the gods save Dionysus--in him he reposed the fullest trust--and after making him drunk Dionysus brought him to heaven."
Pausanias, Description of Greece 1. 20. 3

Being rejected by your parents and tossed out of Olympus could generate a lot of anger and the separation from his people as in the case of Demeter and Achilles indicates the menis kind of anger. Like those two he sat sulking in his tent or more accurately retired to his foster mother’s grotto where he “wrought many intricate things; pins that bend back, curved clasps, cups, necklaces” until the king sends a  messenger begging him to come back.  Which he does, the cosmic crisis is resolved, Hera freed and balance restored.

Maya, I tried to address your question about Hephaestus’ fall from grace and consequently triumphant return.  Now for another question that came up during the book club the other day.  Who is the goddess of Menis?

In the 18 Book of the Iliad Hephaistos tells his wife, that Thetis saved him when his “brazen-faced mother” tossed him from Olympus for him being lame. He says his soul would have known great sorrow had not Thetis and another nymph “caught me and held me”.  He lived there nine years before returning to Olympus No other among the gods or among mortal men knew about him except Thetis and the other nymph.  They know of course since, “they saved me."  Nine years is a long time for one’s menis to fester and rage. But rather than spending that time forging “a weapon in his hand more powerful than the thunderbolt or the irresistible trident,” (Isthmian 8) under Thetis’ guidance he turned his skills (and menis) to delicate jewelry and fine furniture. 

Towards the beginning of the Iliad (Book 1) we hear of a time when the gods revolted against Zeus and bound him in his throne. There had to be some menis there!   Would the perfectly balanced and ordered universe topple into the abyss?  No,   Thetis freed Zeus with opposition from none and restored the Olympic order.

In the last book of the Iliad the gods stand around Olympus wringing their hands and lamenting that they are helpless in the face of Achilles menis.  His wrath won’t abate until Hector’s body is returned to Priam.  So they invite Thetis to Olympus, give her the best seat in the house (Athena’s at Zeus’ right hand) a fancy goblet full of nectar and beg her to convince Achilles to give up the body (and consequently his menis).

So we have seen several time in the Iliad where when there was menis, there was Thetis.  So I would propose that in some positive sense that Thetis is the goddess of Menis

Dear Maya, if you have followed my argument back and forth through the Iliad and find some hint of truth in it, please follow me back to the opening lines;

μῆνιν ἄειδε θεὰ Πηληϊάδεω Ἀχιλῆος
οὐλομένην, ἣ μυρί’ Ἀχαιοῖς ἄλγε’ ἔθηκεν·

Sing, O goddess, the anger [mênis] of Achilles son of Peleus,
that brought countless ills upon the Achaeans. (Iliad 1.1-2)

If we think that Thetis might be the goddess of Menis.  We need to revisit Emily Schurr’s theory that the “goddess” addressed in the opening of the Iliad is not the unnamed Muse we presume.[i]  She suggests, “a previously undiscovered, and highly meaningful, subtext.” Namely that the Muse of the Iliad is indeed Thetis.   

“(A) hint is made even more resonant by the fact that Achilles' mother was, indeed, a goddess (Thetis) - and that the reluctance to name the singing goddess explicitly allows for this alternative interpretation to rise up in the audience's consciousness.”

The subtext and alternative interpretation in the audience's consciousness, strengthens if we accept Menis as an alternative name for Thetis, then sub-consciously we hear;

“Sing, O Goddess Menis of Achilles son of Peleus,
who brought countless ills upon the Achaeans.” 






Thursday, February 13, 2014

TFBT: Muellner’s Menis

I recently enjoyed reading “The Anger of Achilles; Menis in Greek Epic”  by Leondard Muellner. I laughed when this slim volume arrived and thought to myself, “A whole book for one small word?”    You are probably laughing at me right now.  I joined in when I flipped to the index and saw the first and most frequent entry there was “Achilles”.  Yes, we already have a book about menis; Achilles own epic the Iliad. 1


Leonard Muellner writes five chapters in his book. Like Hesiod’s five metallic ages of man interrupted by the “Heroic Age”, Muellner’s five chapters on menis are interrupted by an appropriate one on metis.  His enjoyable narrative and frequent quotes from source materials are peppered with key words in the original Greek and inline definitions.   



Menis as Wrath 

Muellner’s subject is most finely translated in the word, “wrath” with all its violent and divine connotations.  Although generally divine in nature, it is anger with cosmic consequences.  “But menis is not just a term for an emotional state.  It is a sanction meant to guarantee and maintain the integrity of the world order by;
1. maintaining Zeus’ sovereignty over other gods or
2. enforcing the limit that keeps mortals from becoming gods”
The consequence of menis can be “massive, indiscriminate devastation.”   3 

1.  Maintaining Zeus’ Hegemony 

In the Iliad, one continual source of this menis with its potential for massive, indiscriminate devastation is Zeus’ conflicts with his ever feuding family.  In Book I, Achilles recalls a time when Zeus was bound by his relatives.  The King of the Gods is rescued by Achilles’ very mother Thetis.  It is notable that in Achilles’s telling of the tale, there is no resistance to the Nereid’s attempt to rescue her foster mother’s husband.  No threat or negative words is said then or ever after about the gentle sea goddess.  It is as if the rebels are about to embark on some course they dread and Thetis is in fact rescuing them all.  At the end of the Iliad, Apollo and Aphrodite are objecting to Achilles continued and unimpeded desecration of  Hector’s body.  In the grandest arc of the ring theory, Muellner points out “it is striking that the group of gods opposed to Apollo consists of the same three divinities who wished to bind Zeus…in Book 1…Thetis was instrumental in averting menis and protecting the divine order from violent disruption; here in book 24 Zeus chooses her for the same role.”4 

2.  The Limit That Keeps Mortals from Becoming Gods 

Muellner observes that “gods and mortals are not, as Apollo said to Diomedes, the same class.  The traditional role of Apollo in making just this distinction and reinforcing it…”  He documents several places in epic  where  “…Apollo is the god who presides over the limits who transgression incurs menis”2 

Zero, Once, Forever  

Muellner has an interesting theory on proto-events.  The first time an event happens can’t actually be the first time it happens, because there is no context, no one knows what “this” is; until it happens again there is no content.  There has to be a proto-event, a prophesy or a foreshadowing.  So for example; Julius Caesar was never crowned Caesar.  The first “Caesar” of Rome would be Augustus, after which all sorts of princes would be Caesar all the way down to Kaiser Wilhelm and Tsar Nicholas till WWII.  Both titles evolving from the word “Caesar”.   Before I offer Muellner’s own words let me throw out a few quotes that helped with understanding; 

“Chaos (the god) is a kind of tangible nullity.”   This almost a Kabbalah tenet, but it helps us to acknowledge that “Chaos” the parent of the gods is not exactly a god.  Certainly, not a sky god like Uranus the ancestor of the Olympic gods and celestial titans to come.  

 “Uranus actions towards his children are a prefiguring of death, in which created beings are relegated to the space below the earth and cannot emerge.“  But at the time he abuses his wife and children there is no concept yet of “womb” or “tomb”.  It is possible that the sky hovered so low over this lover, that there was no concept of “above” or “below” the earth.   It is Cronus that splits earth and sky and plunges his elder brothers beneath the earth.    

 Muellner writes of a “ metonymic nominalism… whereby a notion such as kingship is capable of being name on the occasion of its second manifestation …    Uranus is not the King because the notion didn’t’ exist during his reign.  One can see, then, that in as much as Uranus was a “zero-degree” king and Cronus a primitive one, Zeus is the “evolved” version, a true king presiding over an evolved and proliferating domain.“   5
“Menis is the opposite of friendship” 

Muellner argues convincingly that menis is generated by the breaking of the relationships  and mutual obligations that define the structure of divine and mortal societies.    Hence, “Heracles…liberation of Prometheus which took place not against Zeus’ desire because he had relented from the anger he had harbored since Prometheus started competing with him in trickery”  So, Zeus’ anger was not due to the consequences of that contest.  In the end what cares a god if mortals have the better portion of the sacrifice and fire to cook it with?  Zeus was hurt by Prometheus’ betrayal.   

Likewise, Achilles wasn’t hurt by the loss of Briseis.  For all his protestations of love, he certainly didn’t rush to reclaim her when events allowed.  He was not hurt by the loss of honor, his place in the hearts and estimation of the Achaeans and gods remained secure.  Achilles was hurt by Agamemnon’s betrayal.  That line of logic makes so much more sense of the Embassy scene.  As Muellner explains, “The Shield of Achilles …depicts a figure in a legal dispute who is violently refusing to accept the compensation offered for a slain relative, exactly as Achilles is refusing to accept Agamemnon’s.  His list of prizes is not a sign of friendship or a tangible recognition of Achilles’ value but… an assertion of the givers’ prestige.  If Achilles were to accept these gifts from Agamemnon, he would effectively accept subservient to him for life.  Because they are intended to be beyond Achilles’ ability to reciprocate.  This why when Achilles actually does receive even a reduced portion of the gifts in Book 19, he does not receive them from Agamemnon himself.   At Odysseus’s suggestion, by then he has apparently understood what is at stake, Agamemnon now brings them in to the middle of the assembly. ..so the compensation of Achilles in binds the social group as a whole to Agamemnon and then reinforces Achilles bonds to the group. 

This is an amazing book full of great insights, much better explained than I have here.  I recommend it highly.

______________________________________________________________

-1  A little aside here; Muellner suggests that because “The explicit central theme of the Iliad is the menis of Achilles…Homeric tradition will not validate the menis of any other (mortal) hero”  thus this Iliadic theme aides in “the traditional mutual differentiation process” with its Odyssean counterpart.

-2 “The divine enforcement of prohibitions is not… a moral and ethical functions to epic gods.  At issue is world maintenance, asserting and preserving the prevailing order of the cosmos, not an individual’s right or wrong behavior. “  Muellner points out “that rules of morality coexist and randomly conflict” with divinely enforced taboos meant to limit humanity.

-3  Muellner restricts his analysis to Homeric epic.  Leaving out the menis of Orestes of which Apollo worries in the “The Eumenides” nor does he addresses the Erinnyes, whose role in the universe is to maintain the integrity of the old world order.  .

-4. Muellner's logic seems to provided even greater and broader powers to Thetis than envisioned by Laura M Slatkin in “The Power of Thetis”.    Thetis; the rescuer of Zeus, the rescuer of Hephaestus (Homer, Iliad 18. 369), the rescuer of Dionysius(Homer, Iliad 6. 135) now becomes the rescuer of the integrity of the world order from the  massive, indiscriminate devastation that could follow should some god exercise that menis.   If Muellner’s theory about menis’ indiscriminate devastation, is accurate, I have to wonder if Thetis is rescuing Hephaestus from the wrath of Zeus or rather she is saving the cosmos from the revenge of Hephaestus the weapons maker.

-5  Jenny Strauss-Clay (The Politics of Olympus, 1989) says similarly of Apollo, “as he did the first time and as he will forever.”  See also my article Once and For Always.