In
May participants at Hour 25 will be studying
“The Best of the Achaeans” and speaking with the author Dr. Gregory
Nagy. As you probably know, Nagy is my hero and I have read the book several
times. The book rambles far beyond which
was the greatest of the Greek heroes at Troy.
(Hint: Achilles!) In hopes of
adding something to the conversation that I haven’t offered before, I opened my
cherished copy and began reviewing the footnotes and my personal notes in the
margins. (I remember hours of delight as
a child, lost in the footnotes in the glossy pages of “Classic Myths” by
Gayley!)
So,
below for you amusement are quotes and insights from the footnotes to “The Best
of the Achaeans.” Page numbers reflect
the electronic version available at Hour 25.
At preface footnote 2, the author is
explaining the insertion of a new foreword in the 20th anniversary
addition. “My present Foreword is a substitute for the original 1979 foreword
written by James M. Redfield, which I will treasure forever. I have exchanged
here the old gold for new bronze, which I need as armor for restating my own
case.” Isn’t that an incredibly
gracefully explanation! For those to
don’t recognize the classical reference here, it is about Diomedes and
Glaucas. They met on the battlefield
before Troy, Diomedes for the Achaeans, Glaucas ally to the Trojans. In the usually bragging and macho displays
prefacing a duel, they discovered that their fathers were friends. In honor of the friendship, they switched
armor and promised to avoid one another hence forth. Homer and all his audience think Glaucus was
crazing for giving away golden armor.
But, for the two warriors the relationship was more important concerns
of greed.
“ areas not included in the world of the
Pythian Apollo correspond to the areas not included in the Homeric Catalogue of
Ships in Iliad II" “The Best of
the Achaeans: Intro footnote 22.
Page
129 “2§11. In the First Nekuia of Odyssey
xi, when Odysseus meets the shade of Achilles, he addresses Achilles as ‘best
of the Achaeans’ . But the Odyssey then has Achilles saying that he would
rather be alive and the lowliest of serfs than to be dead and the kingliest of
shades ". Kevin McGarth points out in class, (Section #7 at Harvard Extension School’s Open Learning
Initiative, ) that
seventy to eighty percent of the Odyssey is told by Odysseus. Hence Homer
is not reporting Achilles comment but rather that liar Odysseus.
If you are not familiar with the “duals” argument in the Embassy scene, here is
a short explanation. In English we have
the word “you” it is used for the second person, singular and plural. Sometimes for the plural, we say, “you
all”. In the Greek they had singular,
dual and plural, as in “you two”. When
the two heralds and three emissaries enter the tent, he only speaks to “you
two”. On page 203 Nagy states, “Thus I am still bound to understand the dual
constructions of Iliad IX 192 as referring to Ajax and Phoinix.” I
follow Nagy in this particularly in light of Achilles use of philo and presumed animosity with Odysseus. As to the heralds I
would point out that in a "classed" society one does not include the
"help". For a better understanding of Achilles'/Homer's use of
the dual form, try it! Talk to a group of people and by body language, eye
contact and word choice exclude someone from the conversation.
Page 283, footnote 17 “It is traditional
for an archaic poem to begin with a word that names the main subject of the
narrative in the manner of a title (in this case, mênis at Iliad I 1), followed
by an epithet and a relative clause setting forth the relationship of the title
word to the main subject (in this case, how the mênis of Achilles was baneful
and caused devastation for the Achaeans, at Iliad I 2–5). Consider also the
openings of the Odyssey, Theogony, Works and Days, Little Iliad, and nearly all
the Homeric Hymns.”
818
“15§2. In the heat of battle, the Trojan
hero Deiphobos suddenly finds that he needs help from his ally Aeneas, and he
goes to look for him: ""And he found him standing hindmost in the
battle for he had mênis always against brilliant Priam, because he [Priam] did
not honor him [Aeneas], worthy that he was among heroes." Iliad XIII 459–461 There is a striking thematic parallelism
here between Aeneas and Achilles, who likewise had withdrawn from battle
because he had mênis against
Agamemnon . The king had not given the hero tīmḗ 'honor'—even though Achilles is not just "worthy among
heroes" but actually the "best of the Achaeans" These themes of mênis/withdrawal/ tīmḗ/excellence are not only”
“present in the Iliad; they are in fact central to it, permeating the
composition in its monumental dimensions.”
Menis is generally translated as
wrath. Primarily, Homer’s usage is restricted
to the gods and Achilles. Page ???
footnote 18. The only exception is the
mênis of Aeneas against King Priam which
must have been the central theme of another epic tradition—this one featuring
Aeneas as its prime hero.” Generally speaking menis is anger with cosmic consequences. Of what possible
consequence to priam could Aeneas' anger be ? Priam was destined to lose
everything. How could Aeneas sitting out a battle screw that up? On the
other hand how could arguing with priam screw up Aeneas' destiny as ancestor of
Rome? I didn’t see the cosmic consequences here until I realized that
Aeneas being angry at Priam kept him away from the front lines and therefore
alive to fulfill his destiny later on.
Page 289 “. In other words, it is
untraditional, since whatever runs counter to the traditional plot of the
narrative is conventionally designated as ‘beyond destiny’:”. Page 284 foot note 6, “Poseidon personally tells Aeneas that his
death at this point in the narrative would have been hupèr moîran 'beyond destiny'. In effect, then, it would
be untraditional for the narrative to let Achilles kill Aeneas in Iliad XX,
since there is a poetic tradition that tells how Aeneas later became king of
Troy; accordingly, Poseidon intervenes in the narrative and keeps Aeneas alive
for further narratives about his future.”. I love how, over reaching; going
beyond your destiny, not knowing your place is being a "hyper-moron".
Achilles
about to duel with Aeneas points out (page 822) “Priam will not place the géras [honorific portion] in your hand on that
account. He has children," Nagy
calls this, "An ironic understatment"
Page 436. “Moreover, the melíē functions
as the word for both ‘ash tree’ (e.g., Iliad XVI 767) and "ash spear”.
Hence Hesiod Theogony 180 “all the bloody drops that gushed forth
Earth received, and as the seasons moved round she bare the strong Erinyes and
the great Giants with gleaming (bronze?) armour, holding long spears in their
hands and the Nymphs whom they call Meliae all over the boundless earth.”
Page 523 “The Bronze Men are nṓnumno
i 'nameless' in that their deeds cannot
be glorified by poetry;”. I have no Greek, but I wonder if in addition to
"nameless" nonumno could mean "unsung"?
Page 526 footnote 38.” Note in particular
that the area by the Hellespont is explicitly smoothed over by the flooding
rivers . I suspect that this volunteered detail is consciously offered as a
variant of the tradition that tells how the Achaeans had made a funeral mound
for the dead Achilles by the Hellespont ). There is then an ironic fulfillment
of the dire threat made by the river Xanthos/Skamandros to bury Achilles under
a mound of silt, as if the funeral mound of Achilles were to be in the end
simply a natural formation adorning the landscape of the Troad. I draw
attention to the irony that the River calls this mound the sêma 'tomb' of
Achilles from which the Achaeans will
not even be able to recover the hero's bones I would argue that this not
irony, but an example of a divine oath being non-revocable. For example
page 501 footnote 48 “Athena was about to
confer immortality upon Tydeus, father of Diomedes, as he lay dying from wounds
inflicted in his duel with the Theban hero Melanippos, who had also been
mortally wounded. What stopped the goddess from fulfilling her initial design
was her sheer disgust at what she saw: Tydeus was eating the brains of
Melanippos. Here, then, is the grisly deed that deprived Tydeus of an
immortality that could have been his—but was passed on to his son Diomedes.
"
Page 542 “We recall the absence and presence of díkē in Generations II/III and
I/IV respectively”
Page 578 “that the waters of the Styx are
an elixir of life. The lore about the cosmic stream Styx applies commensurately
to the actual stream Styx in Arcadia, and in fact the belief prevails to this
day that whoever drinks of that stream's waters under the right conditions may
gain immortality. ”
Page
581 footnote 60 “We are immediately
reminded of the poetic tradition that tells how Semele became immortalized as a
direct result of dying from the thunderbolt of Zeus ).” Well
more specifically Dionysius rescues Semele from Hades and snuck his mom
into Olympus under the name Thyone. But that doesn't negate the law of lightning
and immortality.
Page 587 “immortal and unaging, just as
the gods are. (Hymn to Aphrodite 214)”. Page 649 footnote 70. “These words are the "correct"
formula for immortalization; when the words are "incorrect," as in
the myth of Eos and Tithonos, then the immortalization is ruined by the failure
of preservation.”
Page 690 “Here is my tentative list,
surely incomplete, of alternative ways for the hero to achieve immortality:
1.Being struck by the thunderbolt of Zeus
2.Plunging from a white rock into the deep”.
(I personally would add;
3. Descendant of Gorgophone or Telephassa
4. Married to Helen or Harmonia or Calypso
5. Defeat death
Page 657 “We may note that heroes who
have been immortalized attract the epithet xanthós 'blond': e.g., Rhadamanthys in
Elysium and Ganymedes in Olympus . Menelaos is the hero who attracts this
epithet by far the most frequently in the Iliad and the Odyssey —and he is the
only Homeric hero”
Page 677 “1. Memnon's immortalization
is actually unique, to the extent that the realm in which he lived before his
death as a hero is also appropriate as the setting for his afterlife. For
Memnon, the afterlife is by implication a homecoming.”
