Showing posts with label Aeneid. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Aeneid. Show all posts

Tuesday, October 9, 2018

TFBT: Aeneid or Critique?



“Is the Aeneid a Celebration of Empire or a Critique?” by Daniel MendelsohnI recently read this New Yorker piece on line.  First, I love Mendelsohns' writing style.  A while back, I think many of us read and enjoyed “An Odyssey: A Father, a Son, and an Epic.” 

I was a little surprised how harsh he was on Virgil.  Poets got a sing for their supper and if they want to eat, they’d better play to the audience.  Being a mythologist, I noted he didn’t mention that the course of the Aeneid was the Will of Zeus. Aeneas death at Troy was “beyond destiny”.  He and his descendants were promised sovereignty over the surviving Trojans. 

But, I felt like missed a paragraph towards the end.  He was talking about a book on the Holocaust, interviewing survivors from a small Polish town.  He used that experience to explain Aeneas often confused behavior.  Like the Jewish survivors Mendelsohn interviewed, Aeneas was “a survivor, a person so fractured by the horrors of the past that he can hold himself together only by an unnatural effort of will.” 

 The every next paragraph he is talking about; “about a tiny band of outcasts, the survivors of a terrible persecution. It is about how these survivors—clinging to a divine assurance that an unknown and faraway land will become their new home—arduously cross the seas, determined to refashion themselves as a new people, a nation of victors rather than victims. It is about how, when they finally get there, they find their new homeland inhabited by locals who have no intention of making way for them. It is about how this geopolitical tragedy generates new wars.”  

Was Mendelsohn still talking about the Trojans and Romans?  Or is this piece a craftily coded critique of imperial ideology.


Sunday, June 11, 2017

TFBT: Random Notes on Aeneid 6&7


 I  don’t recall a nurse maid getting heroic honors in Greek myth
 
Virgil summons Erato so he can "tell of the kings of Ancient Latium of its history...." Calliope is the Muse of epic poetry; Clio the Muse history; and  Erato of lyric and amorous poetry. What?    See "VIRGIL’S ERATO AND THE FATE OF AENEAS" by Michael B. Sullivan


 

"Eating our own tables" story is cute.

 

Thereat he bound
his forehead with green garland, calling loud
upon the Genius of that place, and Earth,
eldest of names divine; the Nymphs he called,
and river-gods unknown; his voice invoked
Night, the stars of night then rising,
Jove of Mt. Ida and Phrygia's Mother
he called his mother in the Olympian skies,
and sire in Erebus. 

 

"May the gods give their blessing to what we begin today and to their own prophecies!"

 

Around 7.297 Juno complains that the Trojans didn't die in the plains surrounding  Sigeion .  Of course at that point in the mythic timeline the city of Sigeion hadn't been founded. Not for another 500 years

 

Juno asks if the Trojans think "I have gutted my appetite for hatred?"  Great reminder of Hera's lust for the destruction of Troy in Iliad IV, exchanging for its destruction "My own three favorite cities...ArgosSparta, and Mycenae. Sack them whenever you may be displeased with them. I shall not defend them and I shall not care"

 

Virgil/Juno dishonor the Furies in comparison to Athena/Apollo/Aeschylus treatment of the goddesses 

 

“Now goddesses, it is time to open up Mount Helicon, to set your songs in motion and tell…You are the divine Muses you remember, goddesses, and can uttter what you remem rber. Our ears can barely catch the faintest whisper of the story. “ (7.647)  Reminds me a lot of Hesiod

 

“the twin brothers Catillus and fierce Coras…like two cloud-born Centaurs plunging down in wild career from the snow clad tops of Mount Homole or Mount Othrys, crashing throug the trees as a the great forest opens to let them pass.”  I love the image of two horseman charging through the lines of the opposing soldiers.    

 

Best telling of the Hippolytus/Viribus story



 

Tuesday, May 23, 2017

TFBT: Random Notes on Aeneid 5 & 6



 “The crescent waters of a tranquil bay break through the curving line of cliff on either hand. The spot is of Nature's giving: one single beach lies between sea and hill, ending towards the land in overhanging rocks . . . Here would the nimble choir [the Nereides] of Phorcus wish to bathe, and Cymodoce with dripping tresses and sea-green Galatea." Why Phorcys?  In Greek it would be Nereus.   I also found “the flood maiden Panopea heard him, with all Phorcus' choir of Nereids, and lord Portunus with his own mighty hand pushed him on his way.”(Statius, Silvae 2. 2. 14 ff  

“Achates, the companion of his breast, Goes grieving by his side, with equal cares oppress'd.”  “In the AeneidAchates (good, faithful Achates, as he was called) was a close friend of Aeneas; his name became a by-word for an intimate companion.”(Wikipedia). Therapon?

 “Two doves, descending from their airy flight, Secure upon the grassy plain alight.”  Aeneid 6

 For, when the fatal horse, descending down, Pregnant with arms, o'erwhelm'd th' unhappy town” Virgil is maintaining the Greek pun of “animal litter” and “ambush”  The horse that was the instrument of Fate, heavy with the brood of armed men in its belly.”  (Penguin translation.)  

Dark night had risen in her chariot to command the vault of heaven, when suddenly there appeared the form of his father..." but now farewell.  The dewy night is turning her chariot in mis-course.  The cruel sun is beginning to rise in the east and I have felt the brreath of his panting horses."  The ghost of Anchises departing from his dreaming son Aeneas.

(At the entrance to the Isle of the Blest) Aeneas leapt on the threshold sprinkled his body with fresh water and fixed the (golden) bough full in the doorway.”   I have an image in my mind’s-eye, from Book 5 when Sleep the god, shaking over his (Palinarus’) temples a bough dripping with Lethe’s dew and steeped in drowsy might of Styx.”,It also reminded me of the Vedic-god Indira who promised the demon Namuci not to kill him by day or by night, not with what was wet nor what was dry.  But he wretched off his head in the morning twilight by sprinkling over him the foam of the sea. (Bhagavatam 8:11) 

At Aeneid 6:630 when the Sibyl and Aeneas enter the land of the Blest, I recognized the landscape of every movie about Heaven or a Golden Age I have ever seen.  Is this the prototype of the Western concept of Heaven?  

In these words the Cumaean Sibyl chants from the shrine her dread enigmas and booms from the cavern, wrapping truth in darkness.” [6.98]   

Hecate, supreme both in Heaven and in Hell.  Aeneid 6

Scarce had he said these words when under his very eyes twin doves, as it chanced, came flying from the sky and lit on the green grass.”  Aeneid 6  

Aeneid sacrifices “Proserpine, a barren heifer.”  In many traditions Prosepine and Hades never had children.

“Hither rushed all the throng, streaming to the banks; mothers and men and bodies of high-souled heroes, their life now done, boys and unwedded girls, and sons placed on the pyre before their fathers’ eyes; thick as the leaves of the forest that at autumn’s first frost drop and fall,”  (Aeneid 6)  Once more mankind compared to leaves. “thick as the birds that from the seething deep flock shoreward, when the chill of the year drives them overseas and sends them into sunny lands.”  A hint of better things to come for the souls of the dead as Anchises will explain. 

 Oh, it is such a greater world that waits them!  After Aeneas sees the mystic poetic Orpheus and his heroic ancestors, 
 
 "Others he sees, to right and left, feasting on the grassy field, and chanting in chorus a joyous hymn within a fragrant laurel grove, from where the full flood of the River Eridanus rolls upward through the forest.  Here is the band of those who suffered wounds, fighting for their country; those who in lifetime were priests and pure, good bards, whose songs were meet for Phoebus; or they who ennobled life by arts discovered and they who by service have won remembrance among men – the brows of all bound with headbands white as snow.” 

 Virgil is pointing out that people besides “heroes” make it into the Isle of Blessed, Elysium, Paradise, the Isle of Leuce, whatever you call it.  These are people were poets, priests, artists and people whose good works are still remembered.  

What the poet is not saying is the significance of the reference to Orpheus.  Orpheus represents the Orphic Mysteries.  In the same way that Christians know they will be resurrected; because Christ was, so the Romans and Greeks knew they could escape Hades because Orpheus did.  (Remember?  He was there and back trying to rescue his wife, but made the mistake of looking back instead of concentrating on gazing ahead at their bright new future.)  Likewise Persephone returned so those who attended the Eleusian Mysteries knew they could return. 

The truth that the “little guy”, the ordinary person, women and children will make it to a better world is hidden in most ancient poetry.  The Nordic Sagas sing the praises of the fallen Viking warriors partying it up in Valhalla anxiously awaiting the day when they and the gods take on the forces of evil and chaos.  But when the Universe Tree collapses in flames and sea boils over a new world arises; it is the estate of the god of all good things in Norse Mythology; Balder.  He and his family have lived hidden away all this time in a beautiful corner of Hel’s kingdom.  And when this new world arises there hidden in his forest are the “good people”   


TFBT: Death of the Trojan Misenus




"Triton… when he had hollowed out the trumpet he had invented, took it with him against the Gigantes (Giants), and there blew strange sounds through the shell. The Gigantes, fearing that some wild beast had been brought by their adversaries, took to flight, and thus were overcome and came into their enemies' power." (Pseudo-Hyginus, Astronomica 2. 23)   "[After the Great Deluge had wiped out mankind, Triton) raised his horn, his hollow spiraled whorl, the horn that, sounded in mid ocean, fills the shores of dawn and sunset round the world; and when it touched the god's wet-bearded lips and took his breath and sounded the retreat, all the wide waters of the land and sea heard it, and all, hearing its voice, obeyed."  Ovid, Metamorphoses 1. 332 ff

Misenus, son of Aeolus, surpassed by none in stirring men with his bugle’s blare…by chance he made the seas ring with his hollow shell – madman – and with his blare calls the gods to contest, jealous Triton, if the tale can win belief, caught and plunged him in the foaming waves amid the rocks.”  (Aeneid 6)

Apparently, the Trojan Misenus made the same error as the satyr Marsyas, the archer Eurytus and the Sirens in competing with the gods. This god, Lord Triton was apparently proud of his fame as a “bugler” and would not allow competition  

Aeneas' pilot Palinurus "Headlong he fell" to his death.  I thought for sure he would meet his master in Hades as Elpenor found Odysseus. Instead, But loyal Aeneas heaps over him a massive tomb, with the soldier’s own arms, his oar and trumpet, beneath a lofty hill, which now from him is called Misenus, and keeps from age to age an ever living name.”  

(Elpenor has to settle for heroic honors from the country that finds his body.)